$85,000 UD Legendary Cuts Card May Have Two Fake Autographs!

The one of a kind Upper Deck baseball card featuring autographs from Ty Cobb, Walter Johnson, Babe Ruth, and Honus Wagner might not be so rare after all. The card was pulled from a pack of 2005 Upper Deck SP Legendary Cuts and features four of the five inductees into the inaugural class of the Baseball Hall of Fame (a picture can be seen at http://www.beckett.com/estore/news/?eskin=beckett&a=6520&s=1). A great pull - if it was real.

This card first attracted attention back in November 2005 when collector Barry Scott of Guntown, Mississippi put the card up for auction and sold it for a cool $85,000. But then this story (http://www.signonsandiego.com/sports/20060222-2133-ca-autographfraud.html) surfaced recently. It seems that Kevin Demitros, the 50-year-old airport planner from Milwaukee who purchased the card, was watching an HBO Special on Sports Memorabilia Fraud and shockingly saw his card's authenticity called into question. The same card that he had figured was a "retirement investment." And why wouldn't he? The card WAS from Upper Deck. Upper Deck!

Below is an excerpt from the article:

"Demitros watched an HBO special on fraud in the sports memorabilia industry and saw a scan of his card being scrutinized by someone convicted in connection with a federal forgery investigation. The man claimed two of the card's autographs were fakes

Demitros is now involved in a dispute with the card's manufacturer, Carlsbad-based Upper Deck Co., which stands behind its products but said it is willing to have an independent third party look at the card to determine its authenticity.

Three authentication companies that studied a scan of it said they believed the Ruth and Johnson autographs might not be genuine.

"It's a huge question. It's an opinion," Fitzsimmons said of trying to verify autographs that old."

First off, I hope that the signatures are real. Any fake memorabilia is bad for the hobby. It certainly seems that Upper Deck will do the right thing here and take care of Kevin if the signatures in fact turn out to be fake (they better or they will have a PR nightmare and probably a lawsuit). There is, however, an important lesson to be learned from all of this - no one can ever say with 100% certainty that an autograph is real.

Hopefully Kevin's story will draw more attention to the topic. Upper Deck, the premier card manufacturer, a company that has it's own authentication service that employs industry experts, still may have missed a forgery...on one of their most valuable cards ever!

On the Upper Deck site they claim:

"Autograph forgeries make victims out of unsuspecting fans. Upper Deck Authenticated became the first company to find an answer to the forgery problem by creating an airtight five-step authentication system that assures fans are getting genuine autographs. Today the company has autograph relationships with the game's biggest stars and produces some of the finest memorabilia on the market."

And yet arguably their most important card ever, one that sold for $85,000, included 2 alleged forgeries!

This is not a new thing - I was exposed first hand (on a much smaller level of course) to this last year when a buddy of mine obtained a Mike Vick autograph at the Pro Bowl only to be accused by the buyer of the item that PSA said that it was fake, costing him a sale and hurting his reputation. It illustrated to me first hand that you are never going to know for sure, that the best you can do is pay for an opinion. I went on to lay out an argument about the damage that autograph authentication is doing for the industry (found at http://www.sportslizard.com/article10.php) - not because experts are giving their opinion about the authenticity of an autograph, but because people were being led to believe that they should treat that opinion as a FACT, driving up autograph prices to unreasonable levels for the average collector.

This story just adds to the argument laid out in that piece - the only way to truly know if an autograph in your collection is real is to get it yourself. Anything else - a certificate of authenticity or even a certification from PSA/DNA - does not guarantee an autographs authenticity, it merely increases the likelihood of it being real.

Listed below are more articles related to the above article from the "Sports Gears Memorabilia" article category.

People interested in the above article "$85,000 UD Legendary Cuts Card May Have Two Fake Autographs!" are also interested in the related articles listed below:

What Else You Should Know About Athletic Footwear

Athletic footwear is very common in the sports arena and many people like to wear the shoes because the athletic footwear is very essential for exercise purpose. You can shop for good athletic footwear but some necessary things are to be kept in mind before you are buying the footwear.

Ultimate Adidas Sneakers Is A Comfortable Sports Footwear

In the world of famous and popular shoes Adidas is a common name. You can get all sorts of shoes from Adidas and is needless to say about the quality and the shoes are worth the charges of the shoes. You will get total comfort and your feet will like the touch of soothe from the shoes.

Nike Shoes and Nike Sneakers - Renowned Sports Gear

When anybody is going to the shoe shop with the intention of purchasing some comfortable and good shoe the first name that comes to mind is that of Nike. This company produces shoes for both men and women and all the people like the shoe for the quality and prolonged existence without any major complaints.

This Year's DC Skate Shoes

DC skate shoes are built for skateboarding as well as snowboarding. The incredible technology that was put into this shoe was included high friction so you can shred the mountain with safety. This year DC skate shoes have a brand new winter selection to choose from. There are 11 new killer DC skate shoes. Every one you pass will stare at you with envy at these cool old school shoes.

Why Nike Started to Make Skate Shoes

As we all know by now skateboarding was not a recognized sort when it first began, which is when the metal wheels were made. This was understandable at first since all one could do was roll forward on a skateboard and try not to fall down. For that same reason though nobody really put much effort into skate shoes that offered the support that the skateboarders needed. Not even Nike bothered with skateboarders until it became a popular sport that more than just teens enjoyed.

Types of Ipath Skate Shoes

Ipath skate shoes are not just one more brand in the vast seas of shoes and skate shoes. They are a brand that has their very own style. Their style is an earthy one that anybody can see as unique. Ipath skate shoes also happen to be one of the most comfortable skate shoes you can by.

Some History on the Fallen Skate Shoes

In the year of 2004 the Fallen footwear was begun by Jamie Thomas the professional skater. Thomas was often referred to as "The Chief" and took part in what should have been the partnership between he and the DC shoes company. Unfortunately however, Quick Silver acquired DC shoes later the same year so Thomas finally made the decision that this project would be moved into his own company instead, they were called the Black Box Distribution.