Estate Planning - Capacity Challenges

Wills and trusts have an interesting history in a culture as heavily influenced by British common law as our own. The bequests of wills have been the pole star around which a great deal of mystery fiction has been written where furtive and anxious relatives wait around a long imposing table to hear what is to become of the family fortune and thus; what is to become of them. As usual, fiction and the media give one side of what something has been or is, while the other side of the tale exists behind the scenes or on an obscure back page of a newspaper.

What is not often shown about a will is that it is contested. Perhaps this is because the craving for legal courtroom drama is a relatively new phenomenon, and perhaps because the way the family members behave toward one another over large sums of money is too violent even for television. Wills are contested in long bitter rivalries that often leave no member of the family unscathed. Often there are two opposing camps and each relative must decide which "side" they are going to be on. It is refreshing when the sides earnestly agree that they each wish to bring about what they believe the deceased would have wanted, but it is more often the case in which that is merely the incantation recited to get what each opposing camp thinks is their due.

One means of opposing a will is to suggest that the person making the will was crazy when they made it. That is why even most lay people begin their will with the phrase, "I (so and so) being of sound mind and body...." This legal doctrine is not unique to wills, but affects the right to enter into contracts and agreements of all sorts. In the context of wills, this is called capacity.

Capacity can be broken down into two elements -- first, the will maker must not be mentally deficient. For the most part this means that the will maker must understand what they own, who will get it and the basic arrangements used to get that person whatever it is they are to receive. These elements combine such that the will maker must understand how these elements relate. It seems that video taped sessions where the deceased explains the whole process are changing the applications of this law. There is the deceased on-screen explaining who gets what, why and how and in what way that affects the rest of his/her property. Note that the requirement of mental deficiency is not about what the person understands generally, but what they understand about what they own. It is tempting to wonder if this requirement stems from the fact that the rich are allowed to be 'eccentric' to a certain extent in our society.

The second prong of capacity is whether the will maker is operating under an "insane delusion" or "mental derangement." However, again, this insane delusion or "false belief against reason," is not about anything other than the assets in the will. Provided that someone has an insane belief against reason, it doesn't matter unless it affects the property divided up by the will. If someone believes they see dead people, but doesn't attempt to leave money to any of them, then that is probably all right. Usually, insane delusions come in the form of an irrational belief that someone is not the deceased's child or that the deceased spouse has been disloyal in the conjugal sense. But, again the deceased can hold a whole host of irrational beliefs about matters other than their property, and that would not invalidate their will.

Copyright 2006 Ronald Hudkins

Rate Article

Related Videos
Play Video Estate Planning Guideline	Play Video Estate Planning Failure	Play Video The Problems Of Estate Planning Based On Wills	Play Video Alternative Ways Of Estate Planning	Play Video How To Do Estate Planning

Listed below are more articles related to the above article from the "Estate Planning" article category.

People interested in the above article "Estate Planning - Capacity Challenges" are also interested in the related articles listed below:

 

Asset Protection - Retain Your Wealth

Asset Protection is everyone's desire, but adults share a characteristic - that they may be sued at anytime, for any reason, whether founded or not. Civil actions range from the serious to the frivolous. Did you offend someone today with something you said? Did you cause someone to suffer sudden whiplash syndrome in the parking lot? Are you a professional facing a disgruntled client or patient? Do you own a company employing someone who did something irresponsible on company time? Did you err on the side of caution... or throw caution to the wind?

Estate Administration In Canada

When an individual dies, the assets owned by him must be located and protected. These assets are called as the deceased’s estate. The debts of the deceased must be paid out of the estate assets. After the debts have been paid from the estate, whatever remains can then be distributed among the beneficiaries named in the deceased’s will or according to the provincial law of intestacy. When an individual dies without a will, he is said to have died intestate.

A House Divided

One of the biggest issues seniors face as they get older is how to preserve an inheritance for their children. Their biggest fear is spending all of that money on assisted living and/or nursing home care. As each family situation is different, so is each solution. Perhaps you can learn something from the experience of one of my clients.

Set Up A Living Trust To For the Sake of Your Descendants

Living trusts are usually set up so that any assets may be passed to inheritors or beneficiaries without necessarily going the probate way. Many people have experienced cases where, when owners of assets pass away, the beneficiaries fight over these assets just because there was no established living trust that will directly pass the assets to the real beneficiaries.

Tune Up Your Finances

With the beginning of a new year, it seems everywhere you turn you hear something about self-improvement. There are plans for weight loss, exercise regimens, quitting smoking, going green and more. What about your finances? Even if you think your finances are in 'good shape', everyone could use a little 'tune up' to make sure everything is running smoothly. And it's not as hard to do as you think. There are some very simple steps you can take that can make a world of difference.

Estate Planning - Some Simple Advice

Most Americans do not know how their assets will be divided once they die. Arizona attorney Steve Allen, known as the "estate planning doctor," has started a website to explain the complicated subjects of wills and trust.

Don't Fail to Plan for the Inevitable

The American Bar Association says that 19 percent of Americans do not have a will. Steven Allen, an estate planning expert, says this can cause families more grief and heartache after a loved one dies.