Evidence for Misconduct by an Arbitrator

 By: Ravi Shankar
The Supreme Court of India has vide above judgment (M/s Cochin Shipyard Ltd. v. Apeejay Shipping Ltd. (2015) 43 SCD 113) answered the above question ‘No’ and clearly held that any misconduct by the Arbitrator should be manifestly discernible from record.

The Apex Court was hearing appeal petition filed by M/s Cochin Shipyard Ltd against the judgment and order passed by the High Court granting permission / liberty to Respondent to examine witness i.e. General Manager to establish legal misconduct. The Counsel for the Respondent contended that there was no bar under Section 30 and 31 of the Arbitration Act for adducing oral evidence and it was essential to examine the evidence of the General Manager to throw the light on the proceedings and establish legal misconduct of the Arbitrator.

On the other hand, the Counsel of the Appellant fairly contended that legal misconduct on the part of Arbitrator has to be demonstrated from the records of the arbitration proceedings and evidence of the General manager has already been taken before the Arbitration which could be read by the Court to learn and discern any perversity approach adopted by the Arbitrator.

The Apex Court relying upon catena of judgments on Award vitiated on the ground of legal misconduct by Arbitrator observed that thrust for the examination of the witness by Respondent was to substantiate the plea of legal misconduct, and this misconduct is not attributed to personal / individual misconduct.

Hence, the same is limited to non consideration of material documents by Arbitrator or Arbitrator differing from the significant observation observed by it at the time of arriving at the conclusion. Therefore, the aforesaid can be manifest or palpable from the proceedings of Arbitrator as a consequence of which the award is vitiated. Therefore, in the light of the same, any examination of witness to substantiate the claim of legal misconduct is unwarranted and not permissible.

Consequently, the Apex court partly allowing the appeal, directed that the Learned Civil Judge would requisition the records from the Learned Arbitrator and granted liberty to the Respondent to press the factum of misconduct from the said records.

Conclusion: In view of the above-mentioned judgment, the apex court re-affirmed the law on establishment of legal misconduct of Arbitrator by parties. The Court clearly laid down that additional examination of witness for proving or throwing light on legal misconduct by the Arbitrator is not permissible, and the same is discernible from the records of the arbitration proceedings. The said Judgment will surely protect the arbitrators from unnecessary harassment in the hands of difficult parties.
Artice Source: http://www.articlesphere.com

Related Articles in Malpractice

People interested in the above article are also interested in the related articles listed below:

Quickly report the particular situations for the law enforcement. Firmly insist an investigator been trained in erotic attack situations become allotted to look into. Several law enforcement officials' organizations have particularly qualified sexual assault detectives who're educated to get data a uniformed police officer simply is not necessarily ready for.
Personal injury case is not possible if you do not have lawyers to handle your claim. It is important to have one because lawyers knows how to process this legal matter. Being injured in n accident needs an attention not only for medication but also exercising your rights by having the full compensation from the person who caused that injury. The culprit has the liability to pay all your medical bills and other damages. This is the purpose of the personal injury case in which it is being filed to the higher courts.
Physicians and nurses are expected to have the knowledge training and experience required to detect and react to fetal distress. They are also supposed to dedicate suitable attention to following their patient during labor and delivery. Should they fail to do so their actions might contribute to considerable harm to the unborn baby. In such cases they might be liable for medical malpractice.

More in Malpractice

Excellent, Larry. Thank you for taking the new article directory technology and making it work to the max. I encourage everyone to keep contributing and contributing regularly. I can attest to the fact that this site is already a strong directory in a field of many. Kudos to Larry!

Matthew C. Keegan
The Article Writer


I find it a delight to use both as an author and a publisher. It is full of nice little surprises that make the whole process of writing, reading and publishing articles a complete delight. This is one that comes out tops and beats the rest hands down.

Eric Garner
Managing Director


I did a Google search and came across your site. It was exactly what I was looking for and was elated to find such a broad range of articles. As I am launching a free magazine in a small town in Florida, I wanted to be as resourceful as possible while still being able to provide some content that is interesting and well written. Your site has all the variables in the mix. Excellent Site hitting all the notes in the scale sort of speak.

Mo Montana
Florida, USA

Article Topics

Copyright © 2005 - by Larry Lim, Singapore - Article Search Engine Directory at ArticleSphere.com™
All Rights Reserved Worldwide. All Trademarks and Servicemarks are the property of the respective owners.
ArabicBulgarianCatalanChinese (Simplified)Chinese (Traditional)CzechDanishDutchEnglishEstonianFinnishFrenchGermanGreekHaitian CreoleHebrewHindiHungarianIndonesianItalianJapaneseKoreanLatvianLithuanianNorwegianPersianPolishPortugueseRomanianRussianSlovakSlovenianSpanishSwedishThaiTurkishUkranianVietnamese