Indigenous Women and Their Position in Nineteenth-century Ecuadorian History

 By: Allan Smith
While O'Connor explicitly states that this book is about Indigenous women and their position in nineteenth-century Ecuadorian history, she argues that it is not women's history. Rather, she tells us that gender analysis is the central feature of the book. This is a claim often made by authors exploring gender issues, but seldom accomplished. Using court records, O'Connor argues that the close association of men with agriculture gave them higher social status than women. The difference in the economic and social meaning of marriage on the haciendas illustrates her point. Marriage provided men with increased status and power over their wives.

For women, "marriage symbolized deepening dependence on their male peers as well as on the hacendado" (p.166). The relationship of Indian men to elite power structures was paradoxical in that they were depicted as both submissive (public) and violently domineering (domestic). Her analysis of this relationship, and the feminization of Indian men, is one of the aspects of this study that clearly demonstrates gender analysis and not women's history in disguise. In the final chapter, O'Connor ties together the threads that wind through the book.

Indigenous peoples actively resisted and subverted ideological, political, and social structures constructed by elites. Using the elite's lack of knowledge of Indian communities and social structures, Indians were able to maintain a coherent cultural and social structure that, while weakened by the patriarchal system, protected their communities from complete collapse. Indian women were able to defend community and individual interests by making "the most of elite ideologies whenever possible, often emphasizing their female vulnerability when they interacted with state officials" (p. 198). Women actively regained their voice in the mid-twentieth century when women like Dolores Cacuango began organizing hacienda workers.

This book is a worthy contribution to Ecuador's political, social, racial, and gender history. It shines a light on a period that is vastly understudied. O'Connor employs a rich, accessible, sophisticated gender analysis of the process of nation-building and intersections of gender, ethnicity, and class. The book helps us better understand the ongoing unbalanced gendered relations going on in Ecuador today. This book would be a valuable addition to courses in gender studies, Latin American history, and women's history.
Artice Source:

Related Articles in Book Reviews

People interested in the above article are also interested in the related articles listed below:

Cleopatra VII, the last pharaoh of Ancient Egypt, the reincarnation of the Egyptian God Isis, remains a popular traditional figure in the Western culture. Her legacy survives in numerous works of art and literature including William Shakespeare's tragedy Antony and Cleopatra and the 1963 film Cleopatra. Schiff has portrayed Cleopatra's character in a contemporary way, most relevant to this 21st century. Schiff's writing style is very subtle, meaningful and full of insight that makes the book a compelling read.
An overview of books on modern British art that have been published this year. There are new books out on the artists John Piper, Ravilious, and John Craxton, and on designer duo Robin and Lucienne Day, and Abram Games. It has already been a fantastic year for Modern British Art publications ranging from the very best in British Design to long awaited monographs on renowned masters of modern art in Britain.
At one time or another I think we all have actions we are repeating or addictions we are indulging in that, if we don't stop, it will kill us. At the very least, these actions will keep us from living the life that would really make us happy. I also believe that breaking through these issues can be nearly impossible until we're armed with the right information and tools to help us break through. Change has often been a frustrating and elusive thing for me.

More in Book Reviews

Excellent, Larry. Thank you for taking the new article directory technology and making it work to the max. I encourage everyone to keep contributing and contributing regularly. I can attest to the fact that this site is already a strong directory in a field of many. Kudos to Larry!

Matthew C. Keegan
The Article Writer


I find it a delight to use both as an author and a publisher. It is full of nice little surprises that make the whole process of writing, reading and publishing articles a complete delight. This is one that comes out tops and beats the rest hands down.

Eric Garner
Managing Director


I did a Google search and came across your site. It was exactly what I was looking for and was elated to find such a broad range of articles. As I am launching a free magazine in a small town in Florida, I wanted to be as resourceful as possible while still being able to provide some content that is interesting and well written. Your site has all the variables in the mix. Excellent Site hitting all the notes in the scale sort of speak.

Mo Montana
Florida, USA

Article Topics

Copyright © 2005 - by Larry Lim, Singapore - Article Search Engine Directory at™
All Rights Reserved Worldwide. All Trademarks and Servicemarks are the property of the respective owners.
ArabicBulgarianCatalanChinese (Simplified)Chinese (Traditional)CzechDanishDutchEnglishEstonianFinnishFrenchGermanGreekHaitian CreoleHebrewHindiHungarianIndonesianItalianJapaneseKoreanLatvianLithuanianNorwegianPersianPolishPortugueseRomanianRussianSlovakSlovenianSpanishSwedishThaiTurkishUkranianVietnamese